Representative Betty McCollum said last week that Secretary of Agriculture Sonny Perdue had broken his word and betrayed his responsibility to care for public lands.
She made these remarks in response to Perdue’s cancellation of the two-year environmental review of the mining withdrawal of Forest Service lands adjacent to the Boundary Waters.
McCollum called out this exchange with Perdue on May 25, 2017.
(A transcript of the exchange may be found here).
It’s interesting, and in hindsight it’s perhaps telling, that Perdue answers before US Forest Service Chief Tom Tidwell can. Just about five months earlier, in December of 2016, Tidwell had stated unequivocally that allowing the Twin Metals mine would likely result in acid mine drainage to the Boundary Waters and the surrounding watershed — “an unacceptable risk.” But before Tidwell has a chance to answer — and presumably walk the committee through these findings — his new boss takes it upon himself to respond.
Perdue right away reassures McCollum and other members of the House Appropriations Interior Subcommittee that he and Interior Secretary Ryan Zinke had “already met about this,” and they had agreed that “none of us, I’m not smart enough to know what to do without the facts base and the sound science, and we are absolutely allowing [the study] to proceed.” But despite this pledge, his posturing before the committee (“the buck stops here”), and his invocation of the “Hippocratic oath: first of all, do no harm,”
Secretary Perdue broke his word, bending to political pressure from a foreign mining company and abandoning sound science to give a green light to toxic sulfide-ore mining in the watershed that feeds the BWCA. Like the President he serves, Sec. Perdue’s word cannot be trusted.
McCollum’s statement continues:
The Trump Administration’s abandonment of the Rainy River Watershed mining withdrawal study is a politically-motivated and callous betrayal of their responsibility to care for our public lands. It completely disregards the scientific evidence that sulfide-ore mining in the watershed will cause irreparable harm to the pristine wilderness of the Boundary Waters. The Trump Administration is eliminating sound science from the equation in order to ram through a destructive giveaway to their friends at a foreign-owned mining corporation.
McCollum understood back in 2017 that Perdue was “receiving pressure from the mining industry.” Along with the Department of the Interior, the Executive Office of the President, and members of the House and Senate, the new Secretary of Agriculture was already being lobbied on the Twin Metals mineral leases. Lobbying reports filed by WilmerHale indicate that an inter-agency, full court press was already underway as early as the first quarter of 2017, even earlier than agency calendars or the timeline I have put together from them indicate.
So it’s hard to credit Perdue’s representations to the House committee in May of 2017 that when he and Zinke met to discuss the Twin Metals mineral leases, they agreed that they were not the smartest guys in the room, and they should wait to have all the facts before rushing headlong into any decisions. It now appears their minds were already being made up for them.
Postscript. 15 September 2018. Some notes on the Zinke-Perdue meeting in this Twitter thread.
There’s so much at stake here besides what the news media decides to focus on—air, water, wildlife—thanks for your posts. We need an informed electorate. What to do Louis?
I hope documenting it, establishing a record, getting at the truth, is a good start. Yes, there’s lots at stake! And eventually the circus will leave town. The sooner the better.
Pingback: Twin Metals At Interior – A Timeline | lvgaldieri
Pingback: “America is Not a Company”: Lowenthal Questions Nedd on the Boundary Waters | lvgaldieri
Pingback: What Is Sonny Perdue Hiding? | lvgaldieri
Pingback: An April Set of Boundary Waters Documents, or, Mr. Altikes Comes to Washington | lvgaldieri
Pingback: Documents Delayed and Permits Accelerated: A Critical Minerals Play? | lvgaldieri
Pingback: Secretary of Agriculture Tom Vilsack Should Promptly Review the Trump Administration’s Decisions around Mining in Superior National Forest | lvgaldieri
Pingback: The Latest Records in my Boundary Waters FOIA Case | lvgaldieri